Tuesday, January 22

Book Review: The Best Christmas Pageant Ever

book coverThe Best Christmas Pageant Ever
by Barbara Robinson

I don't remember the first time I read this book, but I'm sure it was before I was in high school. I have read it many times since, and enjoyed reading parts aloud to my daughter this holiday season--though she didn't seem to get nearly as much out of it as I did!

The story takes a new spin on the traditional Nativity scene. I appreciated looking at what a child has heard her whole life, but never really stopped to think about much. Suddenly, her whole world is upended by the Herdmans, a family of scruffy kids who take over the church Christmas pageant. Seeing the ancient tale through their eyes, brings up questions in her mind, and unexpected answers.

I was going to list one of my favorite quotes, but now I can't seem to find my copy of the book. The gist of it is after the first rehearsal the narrator's mom (the director of the pageant) comes home to ask her dad what he would think if he'd never heard the Christmas story before. He thinks about it for a moment, then states that it was really sad no one could find a decent place for a pregnant woman to sleep for the night. Her mom agrees, saying she's never really thought about it, but Mary had to give birth in a barn!


  1. Is this a kids book? I might have to find this one to read. Sounds neat.

  2. Oh, yeah, did I forget to mention that? Thanks for the good catch, Anna!

    I think the narrator is in upper elementary school, so maybe 9-11ish. The story is well written, though, so fun reading for older kids and adults, too.

    The book jacket (which I've found, but still no book) lists the book as ages 8 and up.

  3. I keep meaning to read this one. Hey, BTW stop by and check out my children's lit quiz . . . I'll be posting another one soon, too.


Sorry--I've had to close comments down because I've been getting so much spam.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.